I kinda agree with UD

You must remember that the majority of the voters are teenage girls and they are allowed to vote up to 10 times AND DO. Young girls will NEVER vote for a female over a guy...so this is why PIA is gone, and the good looking kid is still there.

It's kind of like the baseball all-star game...not always the best players get voted in. Same with Dancing with the Stars.

It's hard to control how people vote...and it's why, like Dave, I'm not that interested. Now if they had a SENIOR American Idol, that would be VERY interesting.