The pros and cons you present are of course very subjective. Some of the pros can also be regarded as cons (as you state in some cases), and you could pick many further aspects not mentioned in the list.
To me, Con #4 weighs so heavy it destroys all of the pros.
Even if the Bible says „You shall be jugded by your actions, not by your words“ or similar, for a President the words are actions, given his strong influence as a role model.
Trump has shown that he does not clearly stand behind the equal value of every human irrespective of ethnicity, gender and other innate characteristics. Lately, he has also shown more clearly how valuable he holds the democratic system. This is so fundamental that I wouldn‘t know any US President who has ever been such a threat to fundamental values and ethics.