Originally posted by captain Russ: Maby the audience can't tell the difference between a Hammond and a copy...but I can, and being satisfied with your sound is a big part of playing/performing enjoyment.
Russ
You may be right about personal enjoyment comfort zone & pros know what a real B3 sounds like, Russ I'll agree with you there.....but sometimes what WE as musicians enjoy & play could go against you vs what the audience likes & what needs to be played to make a living on each venue....
Let me explain Russ...I see too many musicians play what they love to play with total disregard to what the audience likes & in return they just get less & less work till they are no more on the circuit... Playing what you love at home is one thing....playing to make the audience happy is another whether you like it or not...its a job like any other. Times are changin real fast out here eh?
Registered: 01/02/04
Posts: 7305
Loc: Lexington, Ky, USA
Donny, I agree with what you say relative to playing what the audience likes vs only playing what the player likes. My point was, in response to your question about whether the audience can tell the difference between a real B and an alternative, I said that if the audience can't tell the difference they don't care what the choice is. in that case, to me, the only thing that matters then is what I want to play(real or fake B).
Originally posted by Dnj: ...I see too many musicians play what they love to play with total disregard to what the audience likes & in return they just get less & less work till they are no more on the circuit... Playing what you love at home is one thing....playing to make the audience happy is another whether you like it or not...
EXCEPT.....the biggest and best in the industry seem to play what they want and let the audience come to THEM. It depends on what your goals are. For the journeyman professional, you're right, Donny, but you're never going to get beyond a certain level playing "Alley Cat", no matter how much that little ol' lady in the audience likes it. Soooooo, if you've got ambitions but still feel that you must play "Moon River", it had better be a kick-ass version. JMO.
chas
_________________________
"Faith means not wanting to know what is true." [Nietzsche]
But here we are, discussing the pros and cons of a real B3 on an arranger forum, arguably the most 'fake' way to make music out there.....
Long before the difference between a real B3 and a clone makes any difference to an audience, the difference between a real bassist and drummer and an arranger has already been noticed.......
_________________________
An arranger is just a tool. What matters is what you build with it..!
P.S. We are going on holiday,tomorrow 19-1-007, to Spain for a week,Looking forward to some sun shine.It's a bit windy in the U. K. at the momment!! By for now Fred.
Originally posted by Diki: But here we are, discussing the pros and cons of a real B3 on an arranger forum, arguably the most 'fake' way to make music out there...........
Excactly Diki I agree......but you know something? I love it !! I have moved on....yes I have the memories of my big band days but arrangers allow me to make a living playing music, I do it my way without regard to any naysayers....just the fact that a person even "PLAYS" an instrument is unique enough in this high tech world.... Have a wonderful musical day & play music...