Hi folks. when I attempted to reply to: SZ member "MDorantes: following posting thread , I got an http error message. I've since learned (from our Moderator, Nigel) that this occured because a special character (in this case: percent signs) was included in the topic heading.

To allow people to reply to Manuel Dorantes pertinent arranger keyboard topic queston, I re-posted Manuel's original topic thread question here, and encourage input:

Playing the keyboard is a hobby for me. I personally hate the idea of playing midi files on a keyboard even if i mute the main part and play it myself. It just doesnt feel right. If i want to play a midi file i use my pc...for me its a rule to be in control of everything..that way theres a greater sense of originality too.

I never use SMF and I agree with rolandfan...I like having control over the chord changes and the direction of the song.

Ian

Well, you could try just muting the instrument parts and go with B&D, or play as much as you can and put in what parts you need........ Some of the newer arrangers allow you to put in 'markers' to allow you to re-arrange an SMF just like you were playing a Style,,,,,,,,,

For me, the biggest advantage of SMFs is that I can use my left hand for the bender for solos, close to impossible if you've GOT to trigger the chords, plus it allows me to take the odd trombone solo.......... try doing THAT in arranger mode.

Don't get me wrong, arranger mode (or LH bass and arranger drums) are all useful modes for many songs, but don't get too tied to any one mode, they ALL have their uses.......... You wouldn't go round a golf course with just a 3-iron, would you? Everybody needs a putter and a little wood from time to time ;-)

Been playing organs and keyboards for 28 years or so and I've never once had to use a GM/SMF for any song I've wanted to play.
Obviously the arranger styles are pre recorded notes etc but you lot know what I mean - Keep it 100% live as possible, that's my motto.
I do actually do backing tracks for singers on the pro UK club circuit and some who do the ships and army bases using things like Pro tools, Cubase.... but that's a hobby of mine when I've not got my head buried in a synth or T2.
I always tweak any keyboard I have rather than use the internal styles and sound set. I think it's a must for anyone to learn how to use what they've purchased if they've got the time and know how, editing sounds and styles opens up a whole new ball game and you reap the rewards at the end of all your hard work put in.
Enjoy your music, you only live once

I use internal styles, many tweaked, 95 per cent of the time. Of the 120-some songs in our duo's repertoire I use SMFs for six songs which I feel I can't get close enough with the keyboard alone.

This is an old question and a hot one too.

What I like in an arranger is the versatility, the great variety of ways it can be used to play and/or entertain. I use my arrangers in every possible way:

1) In a pop/rock band I mostly use it like a synthetizer. When the bassist misses rehersals I play LH bass a lot. Most used sounds: piano, rhodes, organ, violin, bagpipes, some guitars, strings, fingered bass, some layered sounds.

2) In a duo with a guitarrist I never use SMF(s). Sometimes auto accomp mode, other times just LH bass and RH comping or melody with or without the drum loops.

3) In typical solo dance gigs (weddings, for example) I use styles and SMFs (50/50) and tend to use the SMF(s) more in the dancing part of the gig.

4) When I play at home I never use SMF(s). Styles and LH_Bass/RH with/without drums is how I like to have fun.

'Hope this contributes to a civilized discussion

-- José.

[This message has been edited by Route 66 (edited 07-25-2006).]

hey diki... seve ballesteros could!!!he does things (golf wise!) with a 3 iron you would'nt believe
dennis

Seve could probably do any gig in arranger mode, too........

Me, I'm human - I like to keep my options open!

I use about 50% Song specific styles.
This way you get the song recognizable Intro and the song specific groove, but then have the freedom to play it any way and how long you want it.

Aaaaah; I love arrangers.

Eric