Originally posted by spaghetti:
MikeTV,
thank a lot for your very useful replay!
If you could, you would still choose G-70 (or PA-1XPro)?
Interesting question!
Having already used the VA76 for midifile play for a couple of years, the G70 was an obvious candidate as a replacement, as I knew that it would do the job well. As it happened, a used G70 came up for sale at a very good price a few miles from where I live - so I bought it.
When the PA1x series first came out, it didn't have the same ability to link a particular midifile to an appropriate range of live keyboard part settings for instant recall later (or if it could, it wasn't obvious). For this reason only, I went for the VA76 at the time. The move to the G70 gives me the added convenience of the inbuilt vocal harmoniser and it is generally easier to programme settings than on the VA.
However, the Korg now seems to have come up with an equivalent midifile plus live parts handling ability in it's latest operating system version. This being the case, it would have been top of my list for investigating as the VA76 replacement if a cheap G70 hadn't turned up when it did.
If you have any ambitions to use any of these instruments in "style play" mode, the Korg wins hands down, in my opinion. I would never consider using the VA76 in style play mode as it is virtually impossible to control live. Might possibly use the G70 for simple style based stuff, but nothing ambitious. However - used exclusively in midifile player mode, the winner is less clear cut. Korg is likely to sound better, Roland is likely to be easier to use.
If I had no instrument at all, and was buying new, I would go for the PA1x (standard or pro) as being the better all rounder. It just happened that a cheap G70 turned up first, and suited my main purpose well enough.
Regards - Mike
[This message has been edited by MikeTV (edited 11-04-2005).]