Originally posted by Jerryghr:
Your version is good but certainly not what there looking for.
Jerry
It is not, and never will be, my intention to give the people asking for "In-A-Gadda-Da-Vida" what "they are looking for". When I'm playing easy-listening jazz/pop as a soloist in a restaurant setting (that's what I do), the jerks that request this are not seriously expecting an authentic rendition... they're just being jerks. If I can amuse myself at their expense then turnabout is fair play.
True story: by coincidence, last night I was at a nice upscale Italian restaurant where I play a grand piano with accompaniment, and I customarily hand out a songlist to each table with 200 selections ranging from Cole Porter to Sting. The very first table I went to was a nice 30-something couple with a young boy, and as I handed them my list and offered to take requests the guy smarts off: "Do you play In-A-Gadda-Da-Vida?". As he and his wife chuckled at their wit I replied that I would play it right after my opening Gershwin selection, and I walked away. That felt pretty damn good.