|
|
|
|
|
|
#179708 - 08/12/06 12:41 AM
WHAT DO I BUY?????
|
Member
Registered: 11/04/03
Posts: 541
Loc: Australia
|
Guys - I'll (try) to make this brief. I Currently own: VA-7. Need to upgrade to either a G-70, Tyros 2 or Korg PA1X/Pro or possibly one of the E series. I play in a Duo (Australia) called CHI CHI www.chi-chi.com.au (Shameless plug over) I need a keyboard that: 1. Plays midi files back at LEAST as good as the VA7 (sounds wise - epecially drum quality) 2. Has flexible live options (eg the PAX1-pro has 2 midi sequencers allowing you to crossfade songs like a DJ - WOW - is that the best feature EVER for a live performer or WHAT?????) 3. 76 keys with a great feel. 4. Preferably can sample OR has add on samples that can be manipulated. 5. Has some great styles or more importantly has styles that can be MADE great (ie flexible). I don't get care what brand (I admit, Roland would be the least painless conversion for me as I have COUNTLESS Midis that have been tweaked to perfection by myself. I was going to get the G-70 until I read the PAX-1 could crossfade Midis, connect mp3 players, and sample. Is there something now (or on the horizon) I can get that will be "it"? For example will the E-series (80 etc) come with 76 key versions in the near future (or will the Tyros???) HELP!
|
Top
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
#179714 - 08/12/06 06:56 AM
Re: WHAT DO I BUY?????
|
Senior Member
Registered: 09/21/00
Posts: 43703
|
|
Top
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
#179720 - 08/13/06 03:13 AM
Re: WHAT DO I BUY?????
|
Senior Member
Registered: 09/29/05
Posts: 6703
Loc: Roswell,GA/USA
|
Hellboy44, I too, own a PA1x Pro, and agree with everything Spaulding said. I also have a Tyros2 but have had no experience with the G70 (used to have a G1000). I would stop short of actually recommending the PA1x only because I won't recommend ANY keyboard, only share MY experience with it. My own feeling is that the Tyros2 has the easier and more intuitive OS and that certain utility functions are more cumbersome on the PA1X, but in a live gig situation, especially if using the sequencing function, the PA1x may actually be the easier of the two to control. The touch sensitivity of the touch-screen could be better but is not a deal-breaker...you sort of learn HOW to touch it (like with a woman). The OOTB piano is not a problem for me as I think that it cuts through the mix better than the T2 which sounds better when playing solo piano. IT IS HEAVY, but after years of hauling around a B3 and (2) Leslies, I feel like a wimp complaining about the weight of a modern portable keyboard. Still, I wouldn't recommend it if you're over 80 . Good luck with your choice. My only advice; if possible, buy from a place where you can return it (or at least trade it) without too much of a penalty if you don't like it. chas
_________________________
"Faith means not wanting to know what is true." [Nietzsche]
|
Top
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
#179724 - 08/14/06 03:51 PM
Re: WHAT DO I BUY?????
|
Member
Registered: 11/04/03
Posts: 541
Loc: Australia
|
Ok - I get the hint Spalding - you're on the money, I should stop asking questions and audition the PAX-1 myself.
There's not a ton of them around where I'm from, (which is why I asked all the questions) but I'll be doing just that in the coming weeks.
I've come across some revolutionary keyboards in my research for the "perfect" keyboard.
eg - I'd never even HEARD of the Mediastation X-76 - here'a a cut n paste from an experienced user (it's a bit long maybe...sorry).
I can't BELIEVE the features and innovation this thing has!!
If it were readily auditionable (it's a word!) I would buy it in a heartbeat!
Anyway - thanks for all your help everyone - I'll let you know what I get when the time comes....
For now I'll keep reading (as usual) all the enlightening posts in this great forum!
1. The Mediastation X-76 supports 1024+ voices of polyphony. In future upgrades polyphony will be 2000+ voices.
2. The Mediastations polyphony unlike the Oasys does not suffer when you utilize effects, sequencer files, or audio tracks.
3. The Mediastation has a combination DVD/CD-RW drive and supports MIDI files, MP3, MP4, WAV, CD, DVIX, Audio, and Video files.
4. The X-76 can both read and write CD and DVD files.
5. The X-76 comes with 512 MB of RAM, supports up to 3 GB of sample RAM, and supports 24 BIT Gigasampler and WAV files. The Expanded X-76 comes standard with 1024 MB of RAM, expandable to 3 GB.
6. The X-76 can sample and import files in 24 BIT. The Oasys' sample rate is 48K at 16 BIT, not 24 BIT!
7. The X-76 features arranger styles which the Oasys currently does not support. The X-76 arranger section can play back WAV direct from disk or MIDI files, not just arranger files.
8. The X-76 allows the user to playback MP3, CD audio, style files, drum loops, MIDI, and Video files and alter their tempo, pitch, and playback speed in real time.
9. The X-76 does real time BPM detection. This is a great feature if you want to match an audio file with MIDI files and aren't certain what BPM the file was originally recorded at.
10. The X-76 supports with LINUX ARDUR DAW, 256+ tracks of 24 BIT audio, the Oasys just 16 tracks of 16 BIT audio.
11. The X-76 supports with MUSE SEQ, unlimited Audio-MIDI tracks of sequencing plus VST support, the Oasys is fixed at 16 and does not support VST.
12. The Lionstracs utilizes multiple cards for processing so polyphony does not suffer when you use lots of FX or do extensive audio, the Oasys shares a single processor and DSP so polyphony suffers greatly when the processor is taxed.
13. The Oasys has a larger 10.4" TFT color screen but its resolution is low (640x480), the Lionstracs has a better resolution 8.4" TFT (800x600) Silicon Motion 3D VGA. Korg's resolution can't be upgraded because its limited by its processors fixed speed.
14. The X-76 has an SVGA and Video output so you can connect the X-76 up to any monitor you prefer with a resolution up to 1280 x 1024. In fact the X-76 can drive up to three monitors running three different desktops at the same time. Future upgrades will support higher screen resolutions.
15. The X-76 has a PC keyboard and PC mouse port so you can edit, name, save, etc., using the keyboard or mouse.
16. The X-76 has a LAN port as well as USB ports and can be connected directly to the Internet and used to surf the web, update software, or download files directly to the X-76.
17. The X-76 has two Media Players with independent controls that can play back sequences, audio files, video files, MP3's, and more. The players can run together or separately and the BPM and Pitch of each player can be set independently.
18. The X-76 Expanded comes with Native Instrument B4 installed. B4 functions can be controlled from the X-76's real time controls and/or from the touch screen.
19. The X-76 supports multiple VST's and other software. The Oasys can't run these applications.
20. The standard X-76 has (2) open PCI slots plus (1) open AGP slot. The Expanded X-76 comes with (2) open PCI slots and AGP card already installed.
21. All four Main and Cue outputs of the X-76 are XLR balanced, four 1/4" outputs are also standard. The X-76 Expanded has both 1/4" and XLR audio inputs.
22. The X-76 Expanded comes with two gooseneck lamps which makes it easy to see the instrument in any lighting condition. The lamps can be dimmed directly from the X-76's front panel. All X-76's control buttons are illuminated as well.
23. Last but not least, the Lionstracs Mediastation X-76 standard is less than half the price of the Oasys, around $3500.00 USD. The Expanded X-76 is less than $4200.00 USD.
|
Top
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
#179725 - 08/14/06 05:14 PM
Re: WHAT DO I BUY?????
|
Registered: 04/25/05
Posts: 14268
Loc: NW Florida
|
The Lionstracs board seems like a work in progress, and as anyone will tell you, unless you have unlimited time for tweaking and style creation and conversion, how an arranger sounds and plays OOTB is a very important thing.
The one thing you get from the Big Three is very well developed styles, with perhaps Yamaha or the E80 getting the nod for 'best'. A lot will depend on whether you develop your own styles, or expect them to 'pop' as soon as you get your arranger. The Lionstracs arranger is really a sort of 'computer with an attached keyboard' with all the flexibility, and steep learning curves that this implies. And sonically, you will have a lot of work to make it as overall good as your VA7...... While many sounds are spectacular (Giga and B4 especially) they are a lot more work to balance with each other OOTB. All the balance work is already done for you (mostly!) with Big Three arrangers, and there is a far greater range of choice OOTB.
You haven't had a sampler in your arranger prior to now (unless you used the Varios thingy much in the VA-7), so are you sure you will really need one? A BIG problem with hardware samplers is slow load up times, compared to a computer - at best 1MB/sec, and usually the keyboard is dead during load time. So you have to decide for yourself if you just need the sampler for a better piano (which you will definitely want for the Korg!) or you really want to use sampled loops and other highly specialized stuff, which will make the load time more of a factor.......
If I were you, especially in light of your already familiarity with Roland's OS and basic sound (the V-Drums are in it plus a killer piano and the BEST Hammond in an arranger), the G70 is definitely worth trying out. If you HAVE to have a sampler AND 76 keys, then the PA1XPro is just about it, but beware of it's 48 voice polyphony, something that becomes more of a problem if you use a lot of stereo samples.......
As to the future, who knows.....? Maybe Yammie will finally realize 76 keys is not the kiss of death (and add USB2 sample loading)..... Maybe the E80 will come out in a G70 form factor and allow unlimited external patch selection, so you can use a rack sampler....... Maybe Korg will marry a great arranger OS to the Oasis. Maybe Lionstracs will come sounding as good as a Tyros2 OOTB........
We can but dream.....
_________________________
An arranger is just a tool. What matters is what you build with it..!
|
Top
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
#179730 - 08/15/06 03:00 PM
Re: WHAT DO I BUY?????
|
Senior Member
Registered: 07/21/05
Posts: 5387
Loc: English Riviera, UK
|
Hello Hellboy The Wersi OAS instruments (Which by the way have been on the market since 2000, with the software now up to V7) and the Mediastaion are computer based systems built into a keyboard, and so cannot be compared like for like with a hardware arranger, so have a look into computers, softsynths etc to get an idea of how they work. As an example, polyphony is not a fixed amount on these units, and so you have certainly misunderstood the 1024 and 2000 note polyphony. Tip. Think of the Wersi OAS and Mediastaion instruments as a computer and controller keyboard with the addition of a software version of a hardware arranger. Hope this helps
Bill
_________________________
English Riviera: Live entertainment, Real Ale, Great Scenery, Great Beaches, why would anyone want to live anywhere else (I�m definitely staying put).
|
Top
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
#179732 - 08/17/06 12:24 AM
Re: WHAT DO I BUY?????
|
Member
Registered: 11/04/03
Posts: 541
Loc: Australia
|
Well I currently use - not an UPS per se, but a Powerboard with filters, and anti surge protection (one of those big, serious expensive boards - cost me nearly $300 Aud).
I thought a UPS would be too big/costly etc?
I take your point with a laptop setup, but I honestly find them (still) to be too unreliable. I'm happy to rely on one great keyboard that does it all, and an MP3 player (hell, I currently rely on - and have done so for 5 years - a minidisc for sequence playback, and a good old portable CD player for break music.
It's funny, our show IS energetic, and sounds great, but "back of house" I'm still in the dark ages.....!
I guess I'm looking VERY seriously at the PAX-1 to provide everything (with the MP3 and sampling options).....
Forgive me if I sound like a ninny here, but, whilst I have a kick arse computer at home, I plan to use that ONLY at home as the heart of my studio - and really only for recording the keyboard, some live guitar and of course vocals.
It seems that the keyboard sounds more natural (mainly with all the velocity switching - drums etc) I've never like the GM sounds on a PC, and am not smart enough to deal with software instruments.
To be blunt, PC's (live or in the studio) seem to be a 'guitarists thing".
As I am a professional keyboard player, I feel MUCH more confortable editing, playing and recording everything "inside the board". Then let the PC record all that hard work!
Know what I mean?
Silly maybe.....
|
Top
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|