Uncle Dave, you say Roland has the best acoustic piano samples? Have you heard (or, better yet, played) a Yamaha GT-series GrandTouch? It has a
real (not realistic
grand piano action (with hammers), and 30MB of ROM devoted to
one piano sound (sampled from a Yamaha CF-IIIS 9' concert grand). The first model, the GT-1, cost $10k and was in a shape similar to a Clavinova CVP-600 (what I call a fetus grand#148
. The one I heard felt and sounded so real that if I hadnt known it was digital, I could not have determined that without opening the case or looking for the (well-hidden) power switch, reverb knob, and various jacks. It even recreates the sympathetic vibrations that occur when the damper or (to a lesser extent) sostenuto pedals are used.
While Ive never heard one of these, the new GeneralMusic RealPianoPro (do I have that name right?) units might have the technology to beat the GrandTouch. They use physical modelling (a la Yamaha VL), not just samples. I believe a local store has one. I need to check it out. Has anyone here tried one of these? Opinions?
Granted, neither of these are Arranger Keyboards, so this may not be appropriate for this Forum. Maybe you just meant that the Rolands have the best piano sounds
in an arranger keyboard. But it seems to me that Yamaha could easily make a PLG-150GT card to supplement their existing PLG-150PF card (which, as I understand it, basically has the same piano sounds as a P-80 or P-200), with the same 30MB CF-IIIS sample that the GT units have, that could plug into, say, a PSR-9000Pro (or an S-80). They could price it the same as the PF card, giving you a choice: dozens of great piano sounds (PF), or one
awesome piano sound (GT).
Now that Im on the PLG tangent, I say Yamaha should also replace the PLG-150DX with a PLG-150FB. The FB tone module can do anything the DX could do, and then add its incredible Formant Synthesis on top of that! Check out the demo song at
Yamaha#146;s Synth site.