Originally posted by Leon:
ooooo...Scott, I beg to differ, which is s good thing, we each have our own opinions.
Hi Leon: I wholeheartedly agree
that you should play the tune the way 'YOU' like, but if you listen to the classic Eric Burdon & the Animals, or Bob Dylan version, the groove is definitely: 1-2-3-4-5-6 (6/8 feel), and not 1-2-3-1-2-3 feel as you suggest. Listen to the bass guitar line (Animals version). You'll notice that it plays only on 'beat one' of each measure, with the 8th note guitar arpeg & rhythm guitar providing the 1-2-3-4-5-6 (6/8) rhythm feel of each measure.
Originally posted by Leon:
I'm going by the charts that I have seen, not what someone posted on the internet.
Leon, though I certainly agree we shouldn't just go by something posted on the internet either, I also wouldn't rely exclusively on charts & fakebooks either. Many fakebooks & charts often reflect incorrect chords, rhythms and time signatures, and if played verbatim, end up sounding pretty square & squirely, and not what was actually intended by the composer or played by the classic hit artist, in this case Eric Burdon & Bob Dylan. I've performed this tune alot over the years, and with many different bands and never did it in waltz time
. The bottom line is to listen to an actual recording, and then use 'your ears' to determine the feel (groove) of a song. My apologies for sounding so opionated about this, but this is a really important aspect to music that I think WORTH talking about. The notes on paper (charts & fakebooks) are only man's best feeble attempt at documenting what the composer/performer was actually playing. Music comes from our heart/soul, and not from notes on paper. - Scott