|
|
|
|
|
|
#229107 - 03/12/08 02:38 PM
Re: Audya video
|
Registered: 04/25/05
Posts: 14274
Loc: NW Florida
|
What you call a 'slam', I simply call a response to the hype..
No-one has yet made any attempt to clarify about the range of chords, extensions and inversions that the audio loops are going to provide, or whether they will be able to match the range that NTTs or Guitar Modes can provide. The silence is curious, but with the soon to come release (any announced release date, or is it STILL wait and see?), we will al get the unvarnished truth.
There may indeed be many who are less concerned that the choice of chords available may be limited, in favor of the realism of the few that ARE, but I don't think I'll be one of them...
Maybe it's time for Ketron to release some more pertinent information... These loop libraries we are going to be able to import for ourselves, for instance...
Will the Audya read Acidized or REX loops, along with their playing data, or is it up to the user to laboriously slice and dice the vast number that a decent guitar loop library provides? This is a pretty herculean task, and the fact that few exist that aren't already sliced for computer formats attests to just how difficult and mind-numbingly boring this task may be.
It's one thing to have the ability to do something, but just as the T2 sampler shows, if you make the thing proprietary, and cut the user off from most third-party content without a VAST amount of work, few will use it...
I don't believe I am 'slamming' the Audya... I would simply like some unvarnished information about what is the main selling point of this keyboard. Enough with the hype! Now let's hear the details...
Should the folks at Ketron have taken these things into account, I for one will be VERY interested in one, but I need to hear a little bit more than the simplistic accounts so far before I can see this as anything more than an easily overused gimmick.
Let us look at a few scenarios...
How does the Audya deal with playing a loop SLOWER than it was originally recorded? Does it automatically time-stretch the samples, to cover the gap between slices once they are moved apart (speeding up a sliced loop is a piece of cake compared to slowing it down)?
Is there any automatic transient detection to help with slicing rhythmic material, or is it all done by hand?
Will it import Acid, REX and Apple Loops format pre-sliced libraries?
How many chord types and extensions will it recognize, and allow triggering of different loops?
Questions like this need detailed answers, before the promise of this technology is fully realized. Otherwise, it remains a proprietary system, like the 'Live Drums' that already exist in Ketron arrangers we now have, and let's face it, hasn't exactly unseated the Big 3 in market dominance. While Yamaha's Mega Voice technology may not be QUITE as realistic for guitar parts as loops, they are FAR easier to create, edit, and use for ANY chord, ANY guitar sound (at least, Mega ones).
Maybe ANY skepticism is considered a 'slam' by those that wish upon a star that this keyboard fulfills their dreams. Me, my eyes are wide open, and I would like to see what is so far hidden...
_________________________
An arranger is just a tool. What matters is what you build with it..!
|
Top
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|