Originally posted by TedS:
I appreciate the input so far. But why do the folks at Hal Leonard, etc. choose to use Minor 7th and not Diminished in their simplified arrangements? Are Minor 7th chords a better "musical approximation" of the full piano score / bass clef?
If you are stuck with an accordion or a chord organ that has dedicated buttons for Diminished chords (but not Minor 7th), are there any rules for chord substitution? Is it me, or did Diminished chords just fall out of favor during the 1960s?
I think its just the fact that fewer people are studying music in their youth and the market HL is serving with the easy notes series product line doesn't usually want any part of something as "scary and foreign" as a diminished chord. Putting my marketing degree to use, HL has probably seen a difference in sales with the most basic of chord symbols...Once most (easy note)consumers start seeing lots of accidentals, dim, aug chords, etc. they probably put it back in the rack and look for something simpler.
The players who can handle different chords, inversion, etc. aren't standing in front of the easy note series products in the first place...
My 2 cents...
------------------
Bill in Dayton