Originally posted by squeak_D:
I don't know what's holding people back either. Is it fear of being judge on playing skils or something..., I just don't know. It would be great to just hear a STOCK MediaStation without all the user added programs. Just to hear this keyboard with the apps that come standard (including the MS soundset created by Dom's team)
I do not think it has anything to do with skills, having them or the lack of them.
Just look through the many, many posts of negativity (a lot have covert negativity, but it's still there) about the Media Station.
Also look at how certain members treat someone who does try to post and you might gain an insight into this problem.
Sometimes I get the feeling it is all about "massaging" the egos of these people, so they get to feel superior to someone else.
As though they have doubts about their ability and need to hear someone not as good as them to bolster their self-esteem.
Maybe that't too deep, and I am over-reading it.
Who knows.
All I can say is that that is the "impression" I get from some posts.
Especially when it's a theme repeated over and over and over again.
I think it is this reason in the main, that there are hardly any posts (and the fact that this forum does not have the posting capability does not help....NOT a criticism Nigel, just an observation).
Take a look at the Yamaha forums and there are hundreds of musical posts, why is that?
There are posts of songs also on quite a few of the Yahoo member groups too.
So what is it about THIS forum that makes people feel that they couldn't be bothered?
I could make some suggestions, but that would possibly bring on yet another debate of which I would want no part.
Is it an American trait, that everyone HAS to prove themselves? I know that "competition" is endemic in the American ethos, but why do people HAVE to prove themselves. And why are they condemned if they do not?
In my view, having the ability to play well and sing well, or not having it, does NOT invalidate a person's experience or opinion.
A suggestion, or criticism (constructive) does NOT need the poster to supply proof of his/her musical ability, before it is taken seriously.
The outright dismissal of someones opinion, based totally on either an inability, or unwillingness to post examples of them playing is ridiculous.
Why people cannot give the benefit of the doubt to fellow forum members, WITHOUT having to pass some cock-eyed "proof" test is beyond me.
Those who criticise other peoples music, should seriously take a look at what THEY are producing before casting stones.
So Squeak, I think you need to look at "attitudes" on this forum to find the answer to that question of why there aren't more member performances.
BUT, you will need a very long ladder to reach the top of the towers.
Dennis
PS: If you are interested, I may be doing some demos of exactly that, the sounds of the VST's available on the MS used in songs. Perhaps a couple of modified styles as well?.
But it WON'T be on this forum. I will advise when done and where they can be found. Those interested can then check it out, those who are not can please themselves.