On the other hand, one doesn't actually have to PLAY something to comment about well known OS issues, or to listen to supplied demos and notice timing glitches, fills in Variations, and mismatched chords in the guitar part... Do you?
I don't believe the Audya is getting an unfair shake, but something this delayed in production, and this much more expensive than it's competition needs to be held to a higher standard. Just as we cut little slack to Wersi for their $6000+ arrangers that rarely sound as good as a T3 (or even my G70
), we should be equally as sharp in discussing the Audya's shortcomings.
We have got to the point that user demos (I count Frank's in that category, too - he certainly isn't obfuscating the asked questions) are coming out, and we CAN 'hear for ourselves' what it sounds like... So far, other than the drums, IMO I am not hearing anything that a T3 or PA2X can't do (and either of those COULD load up drum audio loops and play them just like the Audya, if their owners could be bothered to do it).
Sure, it sounds good... so does a T3, so does a PA2Xpro. But is it $5000 good? So far, IMO, no... I'm still waiting for that "OMG!
I have GOT to have one of these...!" moment.
So cut US a little slack...
For what the Audya initially promised, for the price point it has arrived at, I think we are cutting it as much slack as any other arranger's launch. I DEFINITELY remember the T3 getting as blunt an assessment during it's launch...