Gary, I'm honestly not sure what the point of your post is here. I've no doubt at ALL that you could pack a Dancefloor with none of those Songs on the now "Infamous New Song List" posted on the previous page, but if you included a couple, (carefully picking and choosing...) a couple of those BIG hits would probably get everyone up just as well as the hits from yesteryear.
A hit is a hit.
I've personally played "I Gotta Feeling" (our Dance remix of it no less) countless times in many Venues, and it gets EVERYONE, Old OR Young either on the floor, or writhing in their seats (in a GOOD way
) which brings me to a question after reading all these posts here:
Do many of you (maybe I'm talking to the U.S. Citizens here) play to audiences that are so narrow in Age-range/Tastes?
Speaking for myself, we (my Wife and I) absolutely NEED to play a huge range of music almost every time we play.
Just last night at a gig we did -
1. Old Time Dance Numbers (e.g. In the Mood, But I Do)
2. Country (e.g. Neon Moon, I just Wanna Dance with You)
3. RnR (e.g. Runaround Sue, You Never Can Tell)
4. Pub/Goodtime (Bad Moon Rising, Mustang Sally)
5. 90's (Mambo #5, Macarena)
6. Top 40 (Tik Tok, Pokerface (mashed with Bad Romance)
and many many MANY more including "out there" kind of songs like "Bad Things" (the Theme to True Blood - works great as a RnR Eight-Step!)
Unless we're doing a specific themed show with a specific audience (RnR or Country/Linedancing shows) we play to audiences that range in Age from 5 to 90 - ALL THE TIME.
(Even when we DO those specific shows I mentioned, we manage to slip in some VERY out of Genre tunes that go down a treat)
I often read here about very specific gigs - is it all about the Restaurant or NH gigs?
Are there lots of specific, "splintered" audiences in lots of specific Venues over in the States?
In Australia, most (public) Venues contain - by and large - All Ages.
I really wanna know.....genuine, serious (and respectful) question here!
P.S. My point is, if we just stuck to a "certain list" of Material, we'd be out of a Job.