|
|
|
|
|
|
#297506 - 10/26/10 11:05 PM
Re: Roland Prelude Discontinued?.
|
Registered: 04/25/05
Posts: 14269
Loc: NW Florida
|
I thought the GW-8 was quite good from a technical standpoint, but it's main problem was that the styles themselves were not mixed that well, and a lot of them weren't even written that well. I keep going on and on about CONTENT, but for an arranger, especially NOT an open one that seems to be popular amongst those willing to do everything from scratch (mind you, with decidedly dodgy results), it's almost the ONLY thing... Roland stopped doing their styles in house quite a while back, and going to MidiSpot, a third party house, looking to make styles that worked in a variety of manufacturers' models has turned out to be a very bad move. From having worked with a GW-8L for quite a while, I can assure you that in the sounds and technology, at its' price point, it was an excellent arranger... But what SUCKS is how well the style developers leveraged that technology. It took me no more than ten minutes per style to tweak them into something FAR more even and usable, but this is post OS2. Originally, when it was released, no editing at all, virtually. Now you have a Makeup Tools system, similar to the G70 etc. (but harder to use because no touch screen, and no detail drumkit editing, either) and you CAN tweak away. But someone needs to tell these idiot manufacturers that they need to pretend that NO editing can be done at all. And that it should NOT hit the shelves until it sounds its' best. I truly believe that Roland needs new blood. It's founding father Ikutaro Kakehashi is now 80, and little innovation is going on. These are certainly difficult times for the keyboard industry... global recession, stiff competition from software instruments, a decline in live music and in music education programs, the list goes on and on. It is hard to see where things will end up. But Roland may well have decided that the BOTHER of making a good arranger, given declining overall sales in keyboards, and their unwillingness to make sure a new release is PERFECT OOTB, isn't worth the trouble any longer. I can hardly blame them. In the meantime, they went out on a high note. I now have a backup G70, and, as I have said for a long time, nothing exists from ANY manufacturer that does what it does best... I have no problem envisioning playing it happily for as long as I can lift it! Were I to need a 'pure' arranger for solo gigs, I might take a look at Yamaha, if they make a 76. In the meantime, five years and counting, still getting wow! comments from everyone I play with, and not the SLIGHTEST desire to move away from it... Not bad, Roland... Not bad! You'll be missed by a lot of mayflies, who are constantly looking for the NEXT best thing, to assuage their lack of, well who KNOWS what they find so lacking in what they have?! I'm just glad I got the BEST thing you ever made (apart from maybe the Jupiter8!)
_________________________
An arranger is just a tool. What matters is what you build with it..!
|
Top
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
#297510 - 10/27/10 09:18 AM
Re: Roland Prelude Discontinued?.
|
Senior Member
Registered: 09/21/00
Posts: 43703
|
Originally posted by Diki: I thought the GW-8 was quite good from a technical standpoint, but it's main problem was that the styles themselves were not mixed that well, and a lot of them weren't even written that well.
I keep going on and on about CONTENT, but for an arranger, especially NOT an open one that seems to be popular amongst those willing to do everything from scratch (mind you, with decidedly dodgy results), it's almost the ONLY thing... Roland stopped doing their styles in house quite a while back, and going to MidiSpot, a third party house, looking to make styles that worked in a variety of manufacturers' models has turned out to be a very bad move.
From having worked with a GW-8L for quite a while, I can assure you that in the sounds and technology, at its' price point, it was an excellent arranger... But what SUCKS is how well the style developers leveraged that technology. It took me no more than ten minutes per style to tweak them into something FAR more even and usable, but this is post OS2. Originally, when it was released, no editing at all, virtually. Now you have a Makeup Tools system, similar to the G70 etc. (but harder to use because no touch screen, and no detail drumkit editing, either) and you CAN tweak away.
But someone needs to tell these idiot manufacturers that they need to pretend that NO editing can be done at all. And that it should NOT hit the shelves until it sounds its' best.
I truly believe that Roland needs new blood. It's founding father Ikutaro Kakehashi is now 80, and little innovation is going on. These are certainly difficult times for the keyboard industry... global recession, stiff competition from software instruments, a decline in live music and in music education programs, the list goes on and on. It is hard to see where things will end up.
But Roland may well have decided that the BOTHER of making a good arranger, given declining overall sales in keyboards, and their unwillingness to make sure a new release is PERFECT OOTB, isn't worth the trouble any longer. I can hardly blame them.
In the meantime, they went out on a high note. I now have a backup G70, and, as I have said for a long time, nothing exists from ANY manufacturer that does what it does best... I have no problem envisioning playing it happily for as long as I can lift it! Were I to need a 'pure' arranger for solo gigs, I might take a look at Yamaha, if they make a 76. In the meantime, five years and counting, still getting wow! comments from everyone I play with, and not the SLIGHTEST desire to move away from it...
Not bad, Roland... Not bad! You'll be missed by a lot of mayflies, who are constantly looking for the NEXT best thing, to assuage their lack of, well who KNOWS what they find so lacking in what they have?! I'm just glad I got the BEST thing you ever made (apart from maybe the Jupiter8!) Crystal ball again?...all unfounded info about Roland.
|
Top
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
#297511 - 10/27/10 09:33 AM
Re: Roland Prelude Discontinued?.
|
Senior Member
Registered: 05/26/99
Posts: 9673
Loc: Levittown, Pa, USA
|
Diki quote.."In the meantime, they went out on a high note. I now have a backup G70, and, as I have said for a long time, nothing exists from ANY manufacturer that does what it does best... I have no problem envisioning playing it happily for as long as I can lift it! Were I to need a 'pure' arranger for solo gigs, I might take a look at Yamaha, if they make a 76. In the meantime, five years and counting, still getting wow! comments from everyone I play with, and not the SLIGHTEST desire to move away from it..." I am in agreement with Diki...I too am more than content if this was the last keyboard I would own....I also found it to be the best all around keyboard I ever played... When Roland does release a new model (and they will.. )....it will have to be something special to make me change...just as the G70 did with my G1000...a deciding factor for me would be the same quality I found in the G70 ..with the added media player from the Prelude...
|
Top
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|