To John, and those curious about Yamaha styles...
Most of the styles on Tyros4 use 4 bar variations, with very few using 2, and quite a few using a mixture of 4 and 8 bars (mainly in Jazz/Gospel/Blues Styles), one of which, Bebop, uses all 16 bar variations.
There are quite a few Movie Styles using 16 bars, and all the FreePlay Styles that I tried, use 32 bars/variation.
It appears that Yamaha wisely uses the
appropriate number of bars to:
1) Suit the
genre of music...some music thrives on
repetition, and some does not...hence the
variety of lengths.
2) If a style works perfectly well with a 2 bar variation, it keeps the style's size small...therefore more styles can be present....however, this is used very sparingly on Tyros4...it has 500 on-board styles nonetheless.
Personally, I have Korg styles that were converted for Yamaha...some are good, and most are bland (to my ears) as
they do not use mega voices.
This is where Yamaha styles really shine, in my opinion, and even 2 bar variations are superb.
Most music has chord changes every 2 to 4 bars and in
regular play, it is sometimes hard to judge if a 4 bar/8 bar variation is any better than a 2 bar.
In regards to the KMA's small keys:
I have a strong feeling that most jazz, classical, and serious piano/keyboard players will, and do, consider them toy like and will not use them
to any great degree, and certainly
not as a main instrument. There will be, as always, the
odd exception.
However, I can see the popularity on SZ, as
most here who will use them, won't be playing a lot of chords in both hands (Donny's KMA demos bear this out to some degree, and again there will be the odd exception) and several will use them only to play, or play along with, SMF.. Those that need more real estate (room) can do as John Smies has been suggesting, and midi it up to a normal keyboard/controller.
As far as the KMA's sound...
it sounds exactly like the 10 year old Korg arranger technology it is based on...PA-50SD on line demos bear this out, and if you are pleased with the sounds/styles, as most are, it should be fine...
personally, I found the Right Hand and solo voices very "old Korgian" and nowhere near what is being used on present day models...of course, we must remember the
huge price difference/advantage.
Having played on PSS mini-key arrangers made by Yamaha, and finding the whole experience very disappointing, I can't say I'd want to be playing a microArranger, except for a bit of fun, and not for long. It obviously has found a place in the hearts of many, and
I applaud the genius at Korg, who was able to
repackage 10-12 year old technology, and make a fair(hopefully) profit for the company, although a dealer would have to sell quite a few KMA to equal one PA3X (or PA-800, or Tyros or S910).
Enjoy guys (and gals)...and happy playing. Think of me when you play a "little tune"
...and, please don't misconstrue my remarks as "sour grapes"...I believe everyone should use what meets and satisfies their needs in a keyboard instrument/arranger, and believe me, if Yamaha was making something similar (especially based on 10 year old tech), my criticisms (and praises) would be mostly the same.
Ian