Registered: 05/26/99
Posts: 9673
Loc: Levittown, Pa, USA
My observation so far...The Ketron is the best (Audio drums).. The BK5 comes real close and they are midi drums..
The s950 audio drums are decent..except they recorded with too much effects and you have to live with it..another observation,,the Yamaha midi drums sound pretty average (another term for poor) compared to their audio tease..
Still waiting to hear a recording of Ketron midi drums..( although I already heard them and believe the BK midi drums out shine the midi drums on the Ketron too)
I recall listening to audio loops in the Audya and substituting them with midi sounds...TALK about being naked..and this is within the same instrument..
The original comment by Diki seems fairly accurate...the BK is pretty close (not better) than audio drums on the Ketron...but the difference is small..and edits are plentiful on the BK..
Yamaha still needs to upgrade the midi drum kits...and audio drums seems to be a tease presently, with a test for future interest..
BTW: They all sound great compared to a decade ago..
Yep... weekend and Superbowl have but a crimp on my posting my BK-7m (which I think sounds a bit better than the BK-5, but that may simply be a Master Compression/EQ issue).
But yes, the only point I have tried to make is that, in practical terms, what LITTLE extra you get from audio drums is more than outweighed by the almost total loss of control you have over them.
_________________________
An arranger is just a tool. What matters is what you build with it..!
Thank You for posting the PSR950 recordings. I did not think any Yamaha owners would man up actually - well done!
As Diki pointed out, At the moment we are comparing Mid range keyboards with Audya which is a little unfair, so we still need Korg PA3X and Yamaha's Flagship the Tyros 4 (which came out after the Audya so should be in the running)
Here’s my take after listening to each example. The Ketron Audya sounded most like a real drummer but a bit too busy for my taste. The Roland sounded the least realistic. The brushes, cymbal and especially the congas gave it a very unnatural sound. The Yamaha 950 seemed to strike the best balance as far as natural sound and feel. I hope we hear some Korg and compare some other styles. I really like these comparisons as it helps make more informed decisions. How many stores in the U.S. could you compare side by side a Ketron, Roland and Yamaha
_________________________
It not the keyboard, it's the keyboardist.