Hello everyone, been thinking again, I know big mistake lol. What keyboard would you use / get if you started out etc if you could "never" use the arranger side of your keyboards or arps if a synth (except for drums)? Ok, never is a bit harsh, but bare with me please.
Except for three things 1. drum rhythms, 2. voice vocoda, and 3. multi voicing/ splitting etc. Ok, with 2. the Vocoda could be an add on as not all boards come with one, but is part of the equation for a singer/player/duo etc.

So why the question, I hear you ask? It sounds rhetorical in some ways and I am guessing some will think it a waste of time; if you have a keyboard already, just turn the other things off.

But , I am looking at it from another point of view, and that is if so myself or yourself were to get just a keyboard for the above would you recommend 1. what you already use or 2. something else ?

Taking in to consideration playability, quality of sounds and quality of key action. Of course there may be some other points to add for what you would look for or want.

Yes, the keyboard would be used solo and with others in a duo or small band say. But the emphasise is on the keyboard in it's own right.

Tas

Just get an organ, (There are plenty of different types out there) that way you can play your own backing and bass, or just the parts that are required in a band.

Bill

Motif XF-7

or

Roland FA-07

I would have said MO-XF7, but Yamaha has not seen fit to make one of those yet.

Nord stage 3... has everything you need... and a very intuitive interface

Thanks Bill, do you have a preference, like the Hammond SK1 or 2 Nord C2 or the Korg Cx3 version? I have played the Hammond XK3 it was good for a lot of styles of music, but, of cause not so much for piano etc.

tnicoson,
I love the Yamaha XS7 oldie but a goodie , would have love to have a go at the XF7 version myself. The S90xs I think might be in the list for it's sounds from the Motif and the keyboard feel.

Backus,

Not seen the new Nord Stage 3 yet, it does fit the bill on all accounts except needing external drum/rhythms ( I think).
Just for interest, you don't think your Korg Pa4x is good enough to stand alone?

Allan

My B-3, of course, or a modern Suzuki made clone (less maintenance), with my old 147 RV. SK-1 system with the 63 would do nicely. All the B-3 stuff, plus a lot more.

I'm currently using the SK-1 over the arranger, and using the arranger only for drums and drum breaks. I'll try a job with the SK-1 and a Midjay soon.


R.

Hi Allan

You will need to try a few out as the operation and sound is very personal, however for gig ready Hammond or Nord with a Ketron SD40 would be a good place to start. If you are prepared to spend more than have a look at the Wersi OAX1 Duo, which is easily dismantled for transport and used in whatever configuration suits the gig. (Also if you can still find one and don’t mind setting everything up beforehand have a look at the Roland Atelier 300 (Not the best to play on the fly though) for a nice little package)

Have fun

Bill

Hi Allan:

My needs (as a songwriter) are different from most of the participants here. With that in mind, I would love to be able to upgrade to a Yamaha PSR-S970 because the transition would be fairly easy and the machine is significantly enhanced with features not available to me on the S910 I now use.

Regards, ----Dave Rice

Thanks Bill, The Ketron SD3 is available but at a price of $2999 here in OZ ouch. Which is dearer than a Yamaha s970 keyboard which Dave would love. If I had a two board setup, one with a Hammer action midi board to get a decent "feel" and then use another keyboard like the s970 as all singing all dancing then fine. I just don't like the feel of the yamaha's keyboard - too plastic and soft with no feed back. Again, the Wersi is not available here at all, so I could not get to check one out.

The other keyboard I looked at was the Roland VR-09, a lot lighter (and cheaper) than it's predecessor.

To be honest, I love the Korg PA4x 76 keyboard, it is way more than I would need , it has basics I need true, but the price tag for the amount of use ( as a none professional)is hard to justify.
I play the Roland RD 2000 at church - the rd700gx before that and a s90sx as well. But these are heavy and too large to cart around now for this old bloke. Plus I have had Casio and Technics and Yamaha arrangers for years; it's an addiction/ love lol.

Hence, I am looking at a change - do I go with my heart or my head.
I do suffer from insanity from time to time , but not that anyone would notice.

Thanks for you advice and help guys......

Allan

Capt. Russ, how do you find the SK-1 for weight and keyboard feel please? Is it a "waterfall" board?

Allan