IF I MAY ... TO TRY TO CLARIFY - and I am using Donny's quote only to clarify my responses ...Below are the posts relative to what I believe has led to a misunderstanding of what I was trying to say:
I would assume when you play an arranger keyboard you are composing songs don't you agree?
Admittedly, I have not watched the video because the thread title didn't interest me that much.
And, no, I don't agree that I am composing a song when playing an arranger KB, because I am playing a song someone else composed ... Even if I am taking an ad-lib solo, I am using the composer's song as my basis ... JMHO
As Rikki correctly surmised, Uncle Dave and I were answering Donny's question about 'composing' when playing an Arranger Keyboard ... If I'm playing "Misty" as a Bossa Nova, I'm not composing a song, but as UD said, I'm arranging someone else's composition ...
However, if I am using a style, multi pads, voices, whatever on an Arranger Keyboard to COMPOSE a song of MY OWN, then I am composing an original song ... So to those of you who have done so (including myself), fear not, YOUR songs are still original compositions ...
It certainly is not my intention to impugn the creative genius or reputation of anyone who writes his/her own music/lyrics regardless of what medium they are using to do so.
My apologies for any misleading statements and also for taking this thread further SOUTH !!!