No problem Fran. If I thought it was a competition, I'd spend more time rehearsing it (and working out a decent solo
). Nice job, but of course you cheat; I notice you post your songs in WAV format while the rest of us dummies render to MP3
. Seriously, you really can hear the difference in clarity and realism. A couple of comments on your tune.
1. Perfect tempo for that style
2. Drums sound really good but a hair too loud (my opinion only)
3. Bass is too loud (maybe not to loud, maybe just to 'prominent' - again, just a matter of taste).
4. Piano too loud towards the end (sounds somewhat unbalanced)
These are all MIXING problems (if even problems) normalizing or, in the case of the piano track, maybe just using a limiter effect (just on the track - alternative is to do it manually - a PITA
).
I know you know that this is offered only as CONSTRUCTIVE criticism and is highly subjective anyway. If you're like me (super lazy), you probably didn't spend a huge amount of time mixing it down. In any case, I'm really glad to see some of us still doing the old classic standards. They all come from the 'golden age of music' but, full disclosure, I do them mainly because I've been playing them for 50 years and don't have to sit down and learn them
. It's also the reason half the chords are probably wrong
. One of the perks of being old, you can get away with so much stuff
.
BTW, if you're ever down this way, let me know. I've met a few ol' fart (but first rate) musicians down here who I know you would enjoy meeting.
chas