Ian, too bad you had to make all those sacrifices at the young age of 29 , but I guess all's well that ends well.

Mo, good stuff. And boy, does it ring some bells. It does make you admire and respect those great (and rare) drummers that are able to stay rock solid throughout a tune without external clues.

I think you may be right about playing with arrangers (or drum machines) helping your timing in general. I guess it makes you get used to playing in perfect time all the time. BTW, I don't think this detracts from or hurts your "rhythmic soul". Probably just forces a good habit on you.

Also, since you mentioned it, I'm always amazed at those players that DON'T tap or show any type of rhythmic body movement. How do they do that? My body just automatically responds to a good strong rhythm. Does make you look cool in a jazz club, though (playing without tapping) .

chas