Originally posted by cgiles:
I think you may be right about playing with arrangers (or drum machines) helping your timing in general. I guess it makes you get used to playing in perfect time all the time. BTW, I don't think this detracts from or hurts your "rhythmic soul". Probably just forces a good habit on you.chas
Chas, this really strikes a chord. I've heard
so many musicians complain about playing with
a drum machine that's it's not "human time"
and they can't or won't have anything to do with it. These musicians all turn out to have
serious time problems, and they cannot keep to the rhythm. they are so used to playing with rhythm sections that adjust to each others' time so much that their time is all over the place. Whenever i'm working a solo
or with my bongo/handpercussion man Madafo,
and i invite someone to sit in, if they are
well-established musicians they often decline or ask me to please turn off the bass/drums.
If a singer comes up, i start to comp for her, then as we hit a groove I use the tap
tempo to bring in a basic bass/drum swing or just drum w/lh bass. Most of the time i see
them have a look of fear and dread come over
their faces, like oh no!!!! But i have found
one great young singer out of UM who loves to
ride on the perfect time, and Madafo is not
an established percussionist yet, so he embraces the steady backgrounds and finds he
has creative freedom he never had before
because I'm relieving him of time-keeping.
If you can't play with a drum machine you
have serious time problems, friends--and the
only way you will fix it is by playing with a drum machine, and/or learning to make in-time
body motions when there is no machine. how do those great drummers do it? i don't know, but
i can tell you this..only the top rank can,
most drummers cannot keep it that solid. there's a lot more to good drumming than any machine can provide--that's true--but at least the machine provides the most important
element..and does it better than any drummer.
------------------
Miami Mo