|
|
|
|
|
|
#118086 - 04/09/05 11:35 AM
Re: New more organic track up
|
Senior Member
Registered: 08/23/04
Posts: 2207
Loc: Dayton, OH USA
|
Alone-
...Your responses are sounding more and more childish. I asked three basic, straight-forward questions to you trying to learn more about what/how you do what you do. What I get in response is basically a smart-ass, defensive rant.
...Look, I couldn't care less what you think about my motivations or what I do musically. This isn't a contest, musically, pissing or otherwise. For the better part of the last ten years, I've made my living doing nothing but music in a medium to small size midwestern town. I don't use midi files, I don't use a sequencer...I rely on my skills as a vocalist, pianist and a musician to create a musical output I find highly enjoyable and that others are willing to pay nice sums of money to hear me do it. If somehow that doesn't pass your particular muster, well, honestly-who cares?
The beauty of this board is the helpful, well intentioned sharing of ideas, suggestions and experiences.
You think you're more intense than most of us? Fine...most of us have grown past that stage...
You want to put down acompished musicians simply because they/we use available technology in a way you don't approve of? Have at it...those of us that do this for a living hear it on a regular basis...no biggie...
Art is important and cool...no question about it. You won't find a single person here who thinks otherwise. I've listened to all of those online song files from a previous link you provided. I haven't stated my thoughts on your work in any way. Now I will: I think its raw, self-indulgent and gets kinda boring after a while. But who cares what I think? Do what you like, as I and most others are...
Finally, you challenged "The Pro" to see if he could do what you do? Can you do what he does?
If you can't function in the exisiting friendly, good spirited environs we enoy here, then you might be happier looking elswhere for a cyber home that is more suited to your specific tastes and beliefs...
PS: Please, dear god, don't just reprint your previous response...
Bill in Dayton
[This message has been edited by Bill in Dayton (edited 04-09-2005).]
_________________________
Bill in Dayton
|
Top
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
#118087 - 04/09/05 01:06 PM
Re: New more organic track up
|
Member
Registered: 12/01/04
Posts: 120
|
"...Your responses are sounding more and more childish. I asked three basic, straight-forward questions to you trying to learn more about what/how you do what you do. What I get in response is basically a smart-ass, defensive rant. "
I answered all your questions so whats your problem? As for childish have you failed to notice what " The Pro " has been posting...does that deserve anything more then cut and paste. Plus your questions were anything but " get to know ya " questions at least in the context of what this thread has been. If you would have asked what voice what effect was used on such and such song it would have been easier for me to tell we were having a friendly conversation.
"...Look, I couldn't care less what you think about my motivations or what I do musically. This isn't a contest, musically, pissing or otherwise. For the better part of the last ten years, I've made my living doing nothing but music in a medium to small size midwestern town. I don't use midi files, I don't use a sequencer...I rely on my skills as a vocalist, pianist and a musician to create a musical output I find highly enjoyable and that others are willing to pay nice sums of money to hear me do it. If somehow that doesn't pass your particular muster, well, honestly-who cares? "
Man half of what seems to be rubbing you wrong wasn't even directed at you. I used some EXTREME examples of what SOME people might do around here that doesn't net them a world of grief.
"The beauty of this board is the helpful, well intentioned sharing of ideas, suggestions and experiences."
Well, many of the things I offer to the boards are EXACTLY that...like when I posted five pages of stuff to help "BrickBoo" get started recording.
"You think you're more intense than most of us? Fine...most of us have grown past that stage... "
Where did I ever say this? I know there are other guitar players floating around here, some drummers, heck even sax and horn players, and ive heard some great keyboard work from members. I do feel I offer something that other members dont...not for any reason of ego just simply cause IM an artist. Much like other members here are inclined to do their own thing and have their own ambitions and offer their own perspective on music.
"You want to put down acompished musicians simply because they/we use available technology in a way you don't approve of? Have at it...those of us that do this for a living hear it on a regular basis...no biggie..."
Where have I stated a name of any member? Heck more often then not I see people around here insulting rock bands or metal bands established accomplished ones. Ive seen people around here insult genres at large ( such as electronica ) simply for the tools used. Ive even seen members here insult an 11 girl that was playing " XYZ." Im not saying its YOU that have done these things...just that this is stuff I see go down on these boards ALL the time.
"Art is important and cool...no question about it. You won't find a single person here who thinks otherwise. I've listened to all of those online song files from a previous link you provided. I haven't stated my thoughts on your work in any way. Now I will: I think its raw, self-indulgent and gets kinda boring after a while. But who cares what I think? Do what you like, as I and most others are... "
No problem.
"Finally, you challenged "The Pro" to see if he could do what you do? Can you do what he does?"
Maybe because he posts random crap in every thread I make thats not the least bit insightful even within some context. If he wants to forthright attack my work ( as he has done )...he should at least be able to do some of it or admit the things that are beyond him. No I cant do everything he does note for note and we have very different setups but I could do some of what he does filtered through what I do. Replace the automated drums with live drums, replace key guitar tones with guitar, replace key bass lines with bass and so on. Only not to insult his work as there are only a handful of songs on his site that I could figure out the general arrangement and instruments by ear and honestly at max I would only do a 4 to 7 part arrangement on any select thing. See I can admit that...did you see " The Pro " admitting he couldn't play Spanish guitar when he doesn't even play guitar, or admitting he couldn't play Dominican style drum work complete with interdependence and rudiments when he doesn't even play drums.
"If you can't function in the exisiting friendly, good spirited environs we enoy here, then you might be happier looking elswhere for a cyber home that is more suited to your specific tastes and beliefs..."
Ive functioned just fine here...only sometimes I fail to see the friendly good spirited nature of the board when. I see people around here insulting rock bands or metal bands established accomplished ones. Ive seen people around here insult genres at large ( such as electronica ) simply for the tools used. Ive even seen members here insult an 11 girl that was playing " XYZ."
|
Top
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|