Originally posted by Beakybird:
My suggestion is that when people like DV start foaming at the mouth over impertinent topics that we just ignore it. You can't reform people like that. I mean if these people go overboard (which DV hasn't yet, in my opinion), then Nigel can boot the person.
Larry,
The problem with DV's posts is that they seem to be criticizing the posts like George Kaye's and Minimix's, who have kindly provided to us advance release information, picture of the upcoming keyboard. While this information has most certainly originated at Roland, there was no harm done to anyone by having this well-intentioned information posted here, which the posters believed to be true and accurate (and which mostly was). I, and I am certain, many others in this forum, appreciate the effort people make to share the the advance information with the rest of the forum members. It helps us reassess or plan (or delay) our purchasing decisions to have the best instruments for our needs. Even those of us who are not Roland devotees, are reading these posts with interest, learning about the leading edge of the technology. This is one of the types of posts which attract me to this forum.
The problem is that by ignoring condescending and deprecating rants like DV's, we create an appearance of ambivalence, and create an impression in the minds of people like George or Minimix that we give irrelevant attacks on them as much credence as to their original posts, and discourage them from posting in the future. As a result, we would be enabling a few grouches to stifle the kind of discussion that makes this forum a lively and entertaining location for us.
While you are probably right in not addressing grouchy posts, I think it is important to express our support to the people being unfairly criticized.
Incidentally, a couple of years ago there was a Korg PA80 web site. On its front page it was a posting of "news", the tidbits of information sent by the author by folks at Korg. I thought it was a pretty interesting site, though I think that as the PA80 became old news, the interest has vaned, and the site closed down. This site was run by a Brit named Craig, who went by the pseudonym DigitalVision. Quite an ironic coincidence, isn't it?