Originally posted by Fran Carango:
Zuki I always gave Korg credit for sounding good...What I never liked was the OS...and the effects operation..
I don't like the PA800 for my personal reasons...Key range, key feel, and the built in speakers..both volume and sound quality...
Hi Fran,
For what it's worth, the 88 note weighted action of the PA588 feels wonderful. Maybe a bit heavier than my RD700GX and certainly different from the instruments I have around here that use FATAR actions (which have always been my favorite).
As for the internal speakers, the are very impressive. I really think I could do a small intimate gig using no external amplification.
I am still getting used to the operation of the instrument. I don't mean the basics of playing with styles, selecting sounds/performances, or playing back smf's. That stuff is very straight forward with no manual required. But for the in-depth MIDI parameters, setting up the song book data base, and so forth, well let's just say that it is different than what I am used to in the GEM products. I won't say better or worse, just different. Actually when I first got the Genesys, I couldn't stand what they had done to the operation as compared to the WK/SK/PS series that I was so comfortable with. But after a very short time, I realized why they made the changes they did and how much more usable the Genesys was because of those changes. I suspect I will have the same revelation with the PA588 in short order.
Thank goodness there are brand choices out there so we all can be happy. You happen to like Roland, I happen to still be very fond of GEM but am being severely seduced by Korg, and 99.9% of the rest of the folks around here are blind to anything not bearing the name Yamaha.
After only a couple of days I have come to the conclusion that the PA588 has a far better piano sound than my RD700GX. I almost bought a couple of piano expansion boards for the RD to try and get a better piano sound, and that just didn't seem right to me. In addition to the pianos of the PA588, the strings, brass, woodwinds, synth sounds, drum sounds, etc. are better as well. And the PA588 has an honest to goodness programmable synth to fully edit any of those sounds or create new ones from scratch. And full sequencing abilities, an extremely capable arranger, complete style creation that is crazy deep if you want it to be. And on and on.
What I am saying is, the PA588 happens to be the absolute perfect instrument for my needs. I do miss some of the features from the PA800/2X Pro like a mic input and vocal processing, internal hard drive, USB stick interface and mp3 audio recording and playback. But in reality, I can plug my mic into my amp which does have a mic input and digital effects (and I have decided that I don't really care for electronically produced vocal harmonies anyway), the SD card interface does the same job as a hard drive and is probably better because I don't have to worry about keeping my speakers away from the keyboard during transport. And if I really need to play live audio files at a gig I can plug my iPod into the audio inputs which is no more difficult that plugging a USB stick into a slot.
These are just my opinions, which may only be worth something to me. And that's fine.
Best Regards,
Dave
------------------
Wm. David McMahan
LearnMyKeyboard
JazzItUp Band
The Modulators [This message has been edited by WDMcM (edited 07-24-2009).]