Musicians use something that they can HEAR is clearly different to anything else out there (and that difference is a good thing ).
Ever hang around a university electronic music department? Yours is a subjective observation based on gigging players. Not all of us have to play to eat.
Sounded like a bunch of blokes wanking around on some synthesizers..!
That's what they are... They're just not using a keyboard to 'wank' on, as you put it.
If the inventors themselves can't get it to sound unique, what makes you think anyone else can..?
I never heard any claims of sounding unique. Just a claim of offering a new method to play a synthesizer.
If the saxophone had SOUNDED like a clarinet, no amount of weirdness would have kept players playing it... but it didn't. These guys are just too into Star Wars (wish they DID play the Cantina scene music, that might have been cool!)
Again, some form of claim to sounding unique, I guess(?) I'm not sure I get your point on this one...
BTW, I thought the arranger evolved out of home organ accompaniment concepts, not some off the wall synthesizer concept. . A natural progression, not some giant leap forward...
Hmmm, let's think about that. My old Bontempi had synthesized everything - a concept dating back to when some guy put two vacuum tubes and a transistor together with a patch cable. Many keyboards with a electrical cord (with some exceptions), can trace their roots back this far.
Look, I'm not saying these guys are great, or I gotta buy one of those. I'm just trying to keep an open mind and applaud their courage and innovative spirit.
Take care,
Dan
Edited for formatting
[This message has been edited by big741.1 (edited 10-10-2009).]