PS - Gary - no question also that Scotty the country boy is going to go up up up. He is an amazing talent!

We record american idol too. Accually I have been recording a lot of shows.

I love watching The Good Wife & Grays Anatomy. But sometimes I'm watching a ball game or working.

My wife hates it but I also record the capitals hockey games.

We have a strict rule that no one tells dad the score of the hockey game when I get home.

Pia & Jocob in the bottom 3 tonight, WHAT?........I don't think they'll go home but it is surly a wakeup call for both.
Stephano is in danger for sure in that company..

Pia goes home .....I guess America voted and decided you cant win on looks alone.....each week they told her to step it up.

I didn't see Idol last night. I walk into work to get caught up and my jaw dropped. Unbelievable that Pia was sent packing. Shocked.

As Donny said earlier, PIA was a great ballad singer, but that's it. Her attempt at a faster tune fell flat IMO and she did not exhibit any stage presence. The judges did encourage her to step it up, but she was able to put it off for a couple weeks. It definitely highlighted a large hole in her abilities. She'll have to really work at improving in that area if she plans to succeed in the future.

Country boy Scotty is ready for CW charts right now, but that doesn't mean he can win this competition. He too is a one trick pony and sooner or later that weakness will be his downfall. My hopes are still on Casey.

I'm still trying to figure out why Paul is still there.

Gary

Lots of little girls have lots of little cell phones ..;

OK, I saw a clip this morning on the news showing the horror and disbelief that the AI judges had at the (obviously) wrong tally of votes from the viewers. Sheesh .... this is exactly why I hate this show so much. They criticize the performers in a non-professional way, they criticize the VOTERS (who may or may not be legit), and they express just how wrong it was for poor Pia to be cut while her song-mate ( who made it) is standing right there thinking ... "Oh, I guess they really wanted ME out".
What a crock.
I'm glad you people are enjoying it, but I still think it's the worst musical show ever...in spite of the (very) few that come out of it with viable careers. It's nothing like a talent show. And, yes ..... why the hell IS Paul in this show at all? I have 3 kids in my school that could send them all home crying, but I'd never support them going on such a farce. It'd be bad for their self esteem, and I'd do everything I could to talk their parents out of it.
As a scripted, predicted, entertainment vehicle, I suppose it belongs on TV, but as a true talent show - it's a total lie.
Rant over. I wish it stayed out of the news too!

This is the first year that I actually might consider going to the tour concert ... my wife seems intent on going, so I may join her ... with all due respect to Donny's choices, I was VERY disappointed Pia was voted off ...
I think she is more talented than Paul (Rod Stewart type) and Stefano - who, by the way, doesn't seem to have much stage presence either ...