I'm lovin' Jacop

Pia Toscano for me....

I have Pia Toscano as a favorite.I am curious to see how far country fans are going to help the country boy by voting for him. At 16, he is remarkable. The 1st three acts were forgettable.

I caught some of the results show last night. The results show is just a marketing campaign to launch a new song and advertise Ford. Ryan Seacrest try's to be to cute with who is safe. You knew the judges would use the save with Casey.

I thought the motown night was full of very good performances.

Did any one catch last nights performance? I really think the talent is very good this year. Pia Toscano is fantastic..

Any thoughts ?

Pia IMO is a dead horse.....shes got the voice but NO stage presence at all....she stands there with no excitement, she's just a pretty ballad singer....

my choices still remains as follows for idol 2011..

1- Jacob Lusk

2- Scotty McCreery

3- James Durbin

Pretty strong opinion Donny.. You could be right. I am very curious to see how far country fans will take Scotty.

What ever happened to last years top 10 ?

I think Scotty and Lauren, the two country singing kids are amazing but I think America will vote like this:
1) Pia
2) Jacob
3) James

As much as the judges like Casey I think he will be in the bottom 3 tonight along with the good looking blond girl who they think sings like Janis Joplin and the guy who sings like Rod Stewart. But, I'll probably be wrong as my wife keeps telling me. Actually I think all of them were good last night but you have to pick 3 to have in the bottom and which one goes home is a toss up!

Pia is FINE isn't she?
My favorite since the early auditions was Jacob.
I couldn't argue with any of the remaining choices really.
This is the first year I've ever watched it. I always record it and watch it later.
DonM

There is a host of amazing talent on this year's roster. I still have my hopes up for Jacob - he has been my favorite from Day 1. Tonight will be rough. It's going to get seriously dicey from here on out. They had 55 Million votes last week. So things are heating up. Good luck to y'all and your favorites!