Keybeds are VERY important to me. This is how I rate the keybeds on some of my boards.

KeyB Duo Mk111 - PERFECT, indistinguishable from a well-maintained B3.

Nord C1 and C2D - Excellent, waterfall of course, nearly as good as the KeyB.

Roland Fantom G7 - 10/10

Roland A70 Controller - 10/10

Roland VP770 10/10

Korg Triton 10/10

Tyros II 10/10

Crumar SEVEN 7/10 10/10 if you like authentic Rhodes action

Korg PA1x Pro 9/10

NumaCompact 2x 7/10 (I'm being generous here)

VX49 Controller 8/10

Graphite 49 Controller 6/10

Of course, all of these ratings are based on personal taste. Also, the SEVEN and the organs are rated based on a different set of criteria due to their design for specialty playing techniques.

chas

I'm settling for the feel of my BK9. Firm but not perfect. the other features of it make it good for my needs. I prefer a piano touch as I feel its more responsive but I understand that would add to the weight of this board meant for playing out. Only drawback to a weighted touch would be organ type aounds which I don't use very much except at home for fun so I wouldn't miss them. So many things to consider with a keyboard I guess you have to make a prority list of wants.

I am with you Chas... In fact the first thing I check on a new keyboard is key feel.. If it feels crappy.. don't even turn it on

I don't understand how players don't mind key feel. Playing comfort and how the key feel reacts to dynamics of the sounds... is everything.

Here is my rating of my keys.

G70 10/10 (just like Chas's A70).

E-A7 8/10 (undersized but decent feel)

Edirol PC-80 controller 7/10

My accordion 10/10

Hammond 10/10

Prelude (as I recall) 8/10

Yamaha np-v60 piano 8/10


Anything I would rate at 6/10 or lower, I wouldn't want to play.


BTW: here is my lineup after Saturday and where they are made

Roland G70..Italy

Roland Prelude...Italy

My accordion....Italy

Hammond...USA


Yamaha , I gave to my Grand daughter

PC80...in the closet.

E-A7...going to my old band

Wow that is an impressive list of rated keybeds.....
I guess the Psr/sx line doesn't stand a chance judging by these comparisons,....but like I said you can adapt if needed to a lighter feel even if its not the preferred.

Yes, too light and you just can’t engage with it, too heavy (Particularly piano action) just makes my wrist ache these days, preferring mainly organ I like a middling keyboard (Usually called semi weighted) like the Fatar semi weighted range.

Bill

Bill I agree a middle ground feel is just right for me these days.....
I would love to play one of those Pegasus models

The Roland A70 might be the best non hammer master keyboard ever...

May i add to that list :

Jupiter80, Fantom 6,7 (Roland) 10/10
Korg pa4x 9/10
Yamaha Genos 8/10 (could have been a 9, if not for the slightly smaller keys)
Ketron SD9 9/10
Korg kronos 61 9/10

In general Roland high end keyboards are the best of the best...
Closely followed by the high end fatar’s

PA3X for 5 years and still tight keys
P-125 almost top line weighted - great bed for price