the difference between Jose and almost every American demo arranger player? Almost every American demo arranger player doesn't use his machine like this fellow does. They just leave the rhythm running and play over it[/i][/b], would the public be more impressed with a keyboard if the demo person was jumping up and down like this?
Tony, I think you misinterpreted what I said. Or maybe I left it open to misinterpretation. I wasn't focused on him playing hop-scotch behind the keyboard or whether they had to drag the audience onto the floor.
One of my peeves that I don't talk about is those who call themselves OMB's and neglect to use all the options at their disposal. The obvious start and stop within a song using the sync start being one of them...also using the style itself as the lead and playing around it, playing two sounds at once (as you already noted I do), changing a style in the middle of a song, using any sound other than the standard piano or electric piano patch, using a looped "fill" or even an "ending" running for 8-16 measures as an alternative rhythm, etc
Simply playing a running rhythm style behind you while you tap out your notes is NOT a OMB to me. It's a man who "leaves the machine running while he taps out his notes."
Since I started playing arrangers I've always looked for ways in my playing to simulate an actual band. That if someone closed their eyes and listened, that's how it would come across.
I've seen lots of demo players play way better than I ever will, but I have yet to see a "demo" man work at sounding like an actual band. Jose, to me, is at least aware there's more you can do with an arranger than just belt out the notes!
I'm going to post a song that I did (Hello Dolly...years ago) where I made it a point to play the trombone and the trumpet close enough to each other that you wouldn't know the sound was coming from one person. What I may lack in playing skills I feel I more than make up for it in using creative playing ideas. That's why I picked up on that "start-stop" he was doing. I said to myself: "at last, someone is using their noodle."
I'm convinced that if more arranger players were to, what I call, "work the machine" that there would be more interest in arranger keyboards.