Originally posted by Nigel:
I think the best sounding music I've ever heard is 33 1/3 LPs played on a high quality hifi system with studio monitors. I think they out perform CDs in terms of sound quality and dynamics. They are just more fragile and inclined to wear over time. CDs really aren't better, just more convenient that's all.
I absolutely agree with this.
In fact I bought a lot of remastered vinyl for cd's which I also have on vinyl just out of convenience, but I recently did a side by side comparison with the same old analoge recordings and remastered recordings, and in fact there is no comparison. the vinyl sounds a lot better, if you think away the noise/rumble and crackling though
The question is of course, is this caused by technical reasons or is it caused by the remastering process or a different musical view by the person re-mastering!
Personally I think it is caused by the person doing the re-mastering, since there are cd's sounding terrific.
A good example is f.i. 'The Soul Cages" of Sting, which is a good example of a superb cd recording with analogue dynamics.
So it can be done, but you need a good master engineer not infected by compressors and limiters...