On a forum like this I admit brutal honesty is not even encouraged as it just comes across as being inflammatory in text which I won't tolerate due to the problems it causes. The forum is for all arranger players not just pro players. If your only response would be brutal then say nothing ... otherwise offer some constructive criticism that may actually help improve the performance.
I don't want any players to be discouraged from posting as that has been a problem in the past and I don't want that to become the case again.